Employment /Severance Agreement
Another component of post-employment plans are agreements that provide income and job-loss protection for the executive in the absence of "cause". The amount of severance pay may trigger excise taxes; the type of executive impacts the final "benefits" the employee derives:
- New Hires - will have a low W-2 history and a greater potential to meet the 3x average earnings threshold that triggers golden parachute related excise taxes. Boards should adopt provisions to replace the initial employment contracts and severance protection given new hires.
- Significant Owners - employment contracts and severance packages are less common for founders or significant owners. They are not automatically offered such arrangements. It is important to consider the need and business purpose of arrangements for a particular incumbent.
- Long-tenured Executives - have significant accumulated retirement benefits or equity-derived wealth. Amending or terminating contracts can be challenging. Appropriate time horizons should be set for when certain features of the arrangement like a 280G gross up will expire or the entire agreement will expire absent an evergreen renewal.
Other specific terms in an employment contract include:
- Job description - the executive's duties and responsibilities, financial control, and personnel and reporting relationships need to be defined in detail.
- Compensation - the rewards for taking on the job are covered: those that are fixed and those that are dependent upon performance.
- Termination - the circumstances under which the executive can be terminated, and what they are entitled to at that time.
- Non-compete clause - prevents the executive from seeking employment with competitors for some time period and denies them the right to reveal confidential company information if they do become employed by a competitor.
CEO Payout Exposure Example
| Program/ Element |
Voluntary Resignation | With Cause | Without Cause | Under Change in Control |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Severance Plan |
$0 Not applicable |
$0 Not applicable |
$xxxx per week One week per year of service |
$x,xxx,xxx 24 months salary and bonus |
| Equity Program #1: Stock Options |
$200,000 Based on xxxx exercisable options; xxxxxx unvested options are forfeited |
$200,000 Based on xxxx exercisable options; xxxxxx unvested options are forfeited |
$200,000 Based on xxxx exercisable options; xxxxxx unvested options are forfeited |
$1,400,000 All options vest immediately |
| Equity Program #2 |
$0 All restricted stock awards forfeited |
$0 All restricted stock awards forfeited |
$1,154,266 (over time) Vesting schedule continues as if an employee |
$1,154,266 All restrictions immediately lapse |
| Equity Program #3 |
$0 Full award balance would be forfeited |
$0 Full award balance would be forfeited |
$1,792,354 Immediate distribution, in stock, of full balance |
$1,792,354 Immediate distribution, in stock, of full balance |
| Frozen Pension Plan | $60,000 annually at age 62 | $60,000 annually at age 62 | $60,000 annually at age 62 | $60,000 annually at age 62 |
| Savings Plan |
$500,000 (Distributed as elected (cash, rollover, installment, etc.) |
$500,000 Distributed as elected (cash, rollover, installment, etc.) |
$500,000 Distributed as elected (cash, rollover, installment, etc.) |
$500,000 Distributed as elected (cash, rollover, installment, etc.) |
| Supplemental Savings Plan |
$800,000 Distributed as elected, or immediate lump-sum if no election on file |
$800,000 Distributed as elected, or immediate lump-sum if no election on file |
$800,000 Distributed as elected, or immediate lump-sum if no election on file |
$800,000 Distributed as elected, or immediate lump-sum if no election on file |
| Other | N/A | N/A | N/A | Continuation of health plans, loss of deductibility, and excise tax gross-up |
Memory Jogger
The most costly scenario to the company when ending an executive’s employment contract is: